The Anglicans had a bad start in Lyttelton as their first church, designed by architect Benjamin Mountford, had to be demolished because the green timber shrank so much that the building became a hazard.

The second attempt, finished in 1860, lead to a stunningly beautiful result that can be seen today. It is built of rather colourful grey to reddish volcanic rock, a little white wooden bell spire sitting on top of the roof, giving it a fragrant and joyful aspect.

The historic stone churches of Lyttelton have fared as badly as the historic stone churches in Christchurch Central. This one was badly damaged in 22 February, but still standing. Quakes on 13 June 2011 measuring 5.7 and 6.0 have obliterated the church.